Балтийский регион
Baltic Region
ISSN: 2079-8555 (Print)
ISSN: 2310-0524 (Online)
International relations
Pages 17-32

Eastern Europe. On the centenary of the political project



This article describes the characteristics of Eastern Europe as a political pro-ject. The author considers the genesis of Eastern Europe as a political region and identifies several periods in its history. The author analyses key features of sover-eignization- desovereignization of the region and examines geopolitical projects of Intermarium. It is shown that Eastern Europe as such is an objective reality, whose history has not ended. At the same time, the author advances and proves the thesis that various ‘Baltic/Black Sea’ cooperation models aimed at isolating Russia act against the interests of all participants of the political process. A number of meth¬ods, including the historical and structural functional analyses and the system ap¬proach are used in the study. The central hypothesis is that, as a political project, Intermarium reflects an important part of the systemic features of Eastern Europe as a political region. However, it is not identical to the region in terms of its geography or political regionalism. The anti-Russian sentiment of the Intermarium project is dominant. Yet, it is not immanent in this group of concepts. Reformatting the Inter¬marium concept in line with the new Moscow-Warsaw-Berlin cooperation model can be considered a feasible political task, which requires an adequate scientific solution. Moreover, Eastern Europe has reached the point of bifurcation. The region may become another new source of instability in Europe. Intermarium projects — a traditional object of research – have to be re-evaluated in the new political and eco¬nomic conditions. This article is a step in this direction.

    1.    Keohane, R., Nye, J. S. (eds). 1970, Transnational Relations and World Poli-tics, Cambridge, Harvard University Press.
2.    Fawcett, L. 1995, Regionalism in Historical Perspective. In: Fawcett, L., Hurell, A. (eds) Regionalism in World Politics, Oxford University Press.
3.    Kazajus, J. 2001, Evropejskaja identichnost' [European identity], In: Evrope¬jskaja integracija: sovremennoe sostojanie i perspektivy [European Integration: cur¬rent situation and prospects], Minsk.
4.    Ushakov, N. А. 1963, Suverenitet v sovremennom mezhdunarodnom prave [Sovereignty in contemporary international law], Moscow.
5.    Lloyd, D., 2002, Ideja prava [The Idea of Law.], Moscow.
6.    Walzer, M. 1997, On Toleration. Lectures on ethics, politics and economy, Yale University Press.
7.    Fukuyama, F. 2004, State Building: Governance and World Order in the 21st. Century London. Profile.
8.    Huntington, S. 2003, Stolknovenie civilizacij [Clash of Civilizations], Mos-cow.
9.    Toffler, E. 2003, Shok budushhego [Future Shock], Moscow.
10.    Brzezinski, Z. 2006, Poslednij suveren na rasput'e [The last sovereign at the crossroads], Rossija v global'noj politike  [Russia in Global Affairs], no. 1.
11.    Ohmae, K. 1998, The End of the nation State, London.
12.    Mandelc, D., Učakar, T. 2011, Perforated Democracy: Disintegration, State-building, Europeanisation and the Erased of Slovenia, Revija za sociologiju, no. 41, p. 27—49.
13.    Garaja, N. (comp.),  2006, Suverenitet [Sovereignty], Moscow.
14.    Ideja suvereniteta v rossijskom, sovetskom i postsovetskom kontekste [The idea of the sovereignty of the Russian, Soviet and post-Soviet context], 2008, Pro¬ceedings of scientific seminar Civilizational context and value of Russian policy grounds, no. 4 (13).
15.    Ivanov, V. V. 2010, Teorija gosudarstva [Theory of state], Moscow.
16.    Ilyin, М. V., Kudryashov, I. V. (eds.), 2011, Asimmetrija mirovoj sistemy suvereniteta: zony problemnoj gosudarstvennosti [The asymmetry of the global sys¬tem of sovereignty: the problem of statehood zone], Moscow.
17.    Voytolovsky, F. G., Kuznetsov, А. V. 2008, Gosudarstvo v jepohu globa¬li-za¬cii: jekonomika, politika, bezopasnost' [The state in the era of globalization: eco-no¬mics, politics, security]. In: Mirovoe razvitie [World development], no. 3, 219 p.
18.    Dobronravin, N. 2011, Nepriznannye gosudarstva v «seroj zone» mirovoj politiki: osnovy vyzhivanija i pravila suveren [Unrecognized States in the "gray zone" of world politics: the survival of the foundations and rules of the sovereign], Saint Petersburg.
19.    «Zamorozhennye» konflikty: perspektivy razreshenija, dinamika i posledst¬vija ["Frozen" conflicts: the prospects for resolution, dynamics and conse-quences], 2007, Vilnius, Centre for Geopolitical Studies.
20.    Simon, M. 2014, Integracionnye processy v stranah Vyshegradskoj gruppy: rol' koncepcii  Central'noj Evropy [Integration processes in the Visegrad countries: the role of the Central European concept], Mirovaja jekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnoshenija [World Economy and International Relations], no. 7, p. 23.
21.    Lykoshina, L. S. 2014, Evropa, Evropejskij vektor razvitija Pol'shi. Voz-vrashhenie k istokam ili poisk novoj identichnosti? [Europe, European vector of de-velopment of Poland. Back to basics, or search for a new identity?], Vishegradskaja, no. 3; Sovremennaja Evropa [Modern Europe], 2014, no. 4, p. 42.
22.    Mezhevich, N. 2014, Borders and Identity in Theory and Practice of the Eastern Baltic Region, Baltic Region, no. 3, p. 95 – 106.
23.    Kuznetsova, Е. 2013, Uskol'zajushhij suverenitet: status-kvo protiv ideo¬lo-gii peremen [Escaping sovereignty: the status quo against the ideology of change], Moscow.
24.    Giddens, A. 1991, Sociology, Polity, London.
25.    Wildhaber, L. 1986, Sovereignty and International Law. In: Macdo-nald, R. St. J., Douglas M. Johnston (eds.), The Structure and Process of Internatio-nal Law: Essays in Legal Philosophy, Doctrine and Theory, Dordrecht, Netherlands, p. 440—441.
26.    Kobrinskaya, I. 1998, Vnutrennie faktory vneshnej politiki v postkommu-nis¬ticheskoj Rossii [Rossija politicheskaja Rossija politicheskaja]. In: Rossija po¬li¬ti-cheskaja [Russian political], Moscow.
27.    Volkov, V. K. (ed.), 1977, «Drang nah osten» i narody Central'noj, Vos-tochnoj i Jugo-Vostochnoj Evropy. 1871—1918 gg. ["Drang nach Osten" and the peop¬les of Central, Eastern and South-Eastern Europe. 1871—1918 gg.], Moscow.
28.    Ludendorff, E. 1924, Moi vospominanija o vojne 1914—1918 gg. [My me¬mo¬ries of the war of 1914—1918.], T. 2, Moscow, p. 98—102.
29.    Romanenko, S. А. 1994, Process nacional'nogo samoopredelenija narodov srednej i vostochnoj Evropy: itogi k koncu 20 veka [The process of national self-determination of the peoples of Central and Eastern Europe: results of the end of the 20th century]. In: Migracijske teme. Časopis za istraživanja migracija i narodnosti, Zagreb, p. 10.
30.    Coates, Z. K. 1948, Six centuries of russo-polish relations, London.
31.    Zgorzelski C., 1996, Przywolanie z pamixci, Lublin.
32.    Swianiewicz, S.  1938, Polityka gospodarcza Niemiec Hitlerowskich, Bib-lio¬teka Polityki, Warszawa.
33.    Kornat, М. 2002, U istokov sovetologicheskih i vostokovedcheskih issle-dovanij v Pol'she (1919—1939). Osnovnye issledovatel'skie centry [At the root of Sovietological and Oriental Studies in Poland (1919—1939). Main research cen¬ters], Zhurnal pol'skogo instituta mezhdunarodnyh del [Journal of the Polish Insti¬tute of International Affairs], Т. 2, no. 4(5), p. 170.
34.    Simonova, Т. М. 2002, «Prometeizm» vo vneshnej politike Pol'shi. 1919—1924 ["Prometheism" in the foreign policy of Poland. 1919—1924], Novaja i nove-jshaja istorija [Modern and Contemporary History], no. 4, p. 43—67.
35.    Genyk, N. А. 2014, L'vov – gorod pol'sko-ukrainskogo konflikta i primi¬re-nija [Lions - a city of the Polish-Ukrainian conflict and reconciliation], EURASIA: STA¬TUM ET LEGEM, no. 1, p. 15.
36.    Gulevich, V. 2014, Doktrina Mezhdumor'ja i evrointegracija Ukrainy [The doctrine of Land Between the Seas and the European integration of Ukraine], Mez-hdunarodnaja zhizn' [International Affairs], available at: URL: http://interaffairs. ru/read.php?item=10346 (accessed 17.02.2014).
37.    Wulf, L. 2003, Izobretaja Vostochnuju Evropu: Karta civilizacii v soznanii jepohi Prosveshhenija [Inventing Eastern Europe: Map of civilization in the minds of the Enlightenment], Moscow.
38.    Tsymbursky, V. L. 1998, Kak zhivut i umirajut mezhdunarodnye kon¬flikt-nye sistemy (Sud'ba baltijsko-chernomorskoj sistemy v XVI—XX vv.) [How to live and die international conflict system (fate of the Baltic-Black Sea system in the XVI—XX centuries)], Polis, no. 4, p. 52 —73
39.    Ilyin, М. V. 2008, Balto-Chernomorskaja sistema kak faktor formirovanija gosudarstv v Vostochnoj Evrope  [Baltic-Black Sea system as the factor of forma¬tion of states in Eastern Europe], Politicheskaja nauka [Political science], no. 1.
40.    Tarasov, I. N. 2008, Ideologicheskoe pereput'e Central'no-Vostochnoj Ev-ropy [The ideological crossroads of Central and Eastern Europe], available at: http:// www.perspektivy.info/print.php?ID=35964 (дата обращения: 27.12.2008).
41.    Т Tarasov, I. N. 2010, Vybor formy pravlenija kak institucional'naja prob-le¬ma postkommunizma: opyt stran Central'no-Vostochnoj Evropy [Selection of forms of government as an institutional problem of post-communism: the experience of the countries of Central and Eastern Europe], POLITJeKS. Politicheskaja jekspertiza [POLITEKS. Political expertise], no. 1. С. 83—94.
42.    Kosciuszko, I. I. 2007, Vostochnaja Evropa posle "Versalja" [Eastern Euro-pe after the "Versailles"], Ser. Slavjanskaja biblioteka [Slavonic library], Mos¬cow.
43.    Smirnov, I. 2007, Mir siloj oruzhija. «Vostochnaja Evropa posle «Versalja» [World by force of arms. “Eastern Europe after the" Versailles”], Radio Svoboda  [Radio Liberty], available at: http://www.svoboda.org/content/article/405502.html (accessed 03.08.2007).
44.    Ryabichenko, А. 2013, Professor Pal Tamash predlagaet sozdat' «Novuju Ganzu» [Professor Pal Tamas proposes to create a “New Hansa”, Rossijskij sovet po mezhdunarodnym delam [Russian Council on International Affairs], available at: http://russiancouncil.ru/blogs/norrsida/?id_4=833 (accessed 22.11.2013).
45.    Malgin, А. V. 2011, «Novaja Vostochnaja Evropa» i strategicheskie inter-esy Rossii ["New Eastern Europe" and the strategic interests of Russia], MGIMO-University, available at: http://mgimo.ru/gpf-yaroslavl/210341.html?sphrase_id= 127957 (accessed 21.12.2015).
46.    Noskov, V. V. 2010, Izobretaja Central'no-Vostochnuju Evropu. K vyhodu v svet kollektivnogo truda pol'skih i francuzskih istorikov «Istorija Central'no-Vostochnoj Evropy» [Inventing the Central-Eastern Europe. By the release of a col-lective work of Polish and French historians "History of East Central Europe"], Dia-log so vremenem [Dialogue with Time], no. 32, p. 323.
47.    Romanenko, S. А. 2012, Mezhjetnicheskie protivorechija, regional'noe sa-mo¬soznanie i politicheskie sojuzy v juzhnoj chasti Srednej Evropy v konce XIX — nachale HH v [Inter-ethnic conflicts, regional identity and political alliances in the southern part of Central Europe in the late XIX — early XX century], Vestnik Rossi-jskij gosudarstvennyj gumanitarnyj universitet Ser. Mezhdunarodnye otnoshenija. Regionovedenie [Bulletin of the Russian State Humanitarian University, Ser. Inter-national relationships. Area Studies], no. № 7 (87).
48.    Brzezinski, Z. 2000, Velikaja shahmatnaja doska (Gospodstvo Ameriki i ego geostrategicheskie imperativy) [The Grand Chessboard (American Primacy and Its Geostrategic Imperatives)], Moscow, 110 s.
49.    Zernack Klaus Polska i Rosja: dwie drogi w dziejach Europy, 2000. In: Wiedza Powszechna, Warsawa, S. 783.
50.    Kazin, F. А. Zakat tranzitologii ili «seraja zona» Evropy? [Sunset transito¬lo-gy or "gray zone" of Europe?], 2015, Centr mezhdunarodnoj i regional'noj politiki [Center for International and Regional Policy], available at: http://www.cirp.ru/
publications/kazin/transition.htm (accessed 21.12.2015).
51.    Brzezinski, Z. 1990, Agonija kommunizma [Agony of communism]. In: Mud¬ragey, V. I., Usanov, V. I. Kvintjessencija: Filos. Al'manah [Quintessence: Phi-los. Almanac], Moscow, 269 p.
52.    Malenkov, G. M. 1949, 32-ja godovshhina Velikoj Oktjabr'skoj so¬cia-li¬sticheskoj revoljucii [32th anniversary of the Great October Socialist Revolu-tion], Moscow, p. 5—6.
53.    Wierzbicki ,A. Nacjonalizm i geopolityka w Europie Wschodniej, 2012, Geopolityka w stosunkach polsko-rosyjskich, Warszawa, S. 111—112.
54.    Nekrašas, E. 2009, Kritiniai pamąstymai apie Lietuvos užsienio politiką, Po¬litologija, no. 2(54), p. 141.
55.    Shishelina, L. А. 2014, Европа, Obrashhenie k chitateljam [Preface], Vi¬she-gradskaja Evropa [Visegrad Europe], no. 3; Prilozhenie k zhurnalu Instituta Ev¬ro¬py RAN «Sovremennaja» [Supplement to the journal of the Institute of Europe, Rus-sian Academy of Sciences "Modern"], 2014, no. 4, p. 7.
56.    Zhitin, D. V. 1994, Geopolitika Rossii: 400 let nazad i segodnja [Geopoli¬tics of Russia: 400 years ago and today], Izvestia RGO, Vol. 126, no. 6, p. 31—37.
57.    Mezhevich, N. M. 2014, Major infrastructure projects and the foreign po-licy of the Baltic states in 2010—2014, Baltic Region, no. 1, p. 7—28.
The article